T.J. Finley enrolled at LSU in the fall of 2020 as a three-star quarterback prospect. In January 2026, he committed to Incarnate Word in Texas — his seventh college program he had been affiliated with.
Finley’s college career was extended by a mixture of circumstances: injuries, an unclear path to a starting role at various stops, family considerations, and an exception that granted players an extra year of eligibility because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Some of his moves were about opportunity, while others were about necessity. After his twin sons were born, he had to consider going somewhere he could make more money. And after a season-ending injury at Western Kentucky, he transferred to Tulane to be closer to his family in Louisiana.
Individually, most of Finley’s moves make sense. But altogether, the pandemic exemption aside, such a career arc would’ve been virtually impossible under the rules governing college athletics just a decade ago.
The last decade has ushered in a dramatic transformation in college sports, where the NCAA Transfer Portal and new name, image, and likeness policies have given athletes unprecedented freedom to move between schools and earn money during their athletic careers.
The transfer portal debuted in 2018, arguably with good intentions and student-athlete welfare in mind. But the system has since been exploited and abused. It’s increasingly common for athletes to play for three or four schools during their careers, even after the extra COVID-year exemptions expired. Since 2023, the number of undergraduate Division I athletes entering the portal has gone from 9,760 to nearly 15,000 in 2025.1
Like Finley, others have started a season at one school and finished it at another. And it’s not uncommon now for coaches or their staffers to contact players during a season to recruit them for the future, promising them more money or a better opportunity. The latest trend now is athletes recently who have spent time with professional teams finding loopholes that allow them to return to college and play.
These trends will persist for years to come until or unless significant policy change is enacted.
Finley’s story is an extreme and unusual case, but it’s an example of a broader shift in college athletics: when circumstances change or a better opportunity appears elsewhere, moving on has never been easier, more acceptable, or more common.
That shift mirrors a larger cultural instinct, particularly among Millennials and Gen Z: evaluate the current relationship according to what it offers, compare it with available alternatives, and move if the return appears better elsewhere.
In other words, relationships have started to look less like commitments and more like transactions.
This logic makes sense in the marketplace or business world, where people frequently leave one job for another that provides more money or a clearer path toward advancement. But what happens when we begin applying that same approach to relationships?
What happens when friendships, romantic relationships, or professional connections are all evaluated by what they offer? What happens when we decide a relationship is only worth maintaining if the return on investment of time, energy, or attention is high enough?
When people have limited time and an enormous amount of competing priorities, data shows that’s exactly what happens. We become more selective about where and with whom to spend that time.
This is the logic of a transactional relationship. Whether platonic or romantic, it’s evaluated through a lens of, “What can this person do for me?” or “What can this person give me?” Along with college athletes, young adults are now coming of age in an environment where these types of relationships are becoming increasingly normalized.
Relationships that provide some mutual benefit aren’t always inherently bad. Business relationships, professional networking, and even some friendships naturally involve reciprocity. Not everyone is meant to be your closest friend, and there’s nothing wrong with having acquaintances or career associates.
The problem comes when utility is the primary measure of a person’s value to us.
Romance in a World of Endless Options
Romantic relationships may be one of the clearest places we see this play out.
Dating apps have made it easier than ever to meet people outside of our immediate social circles, while social media gives us an endless stream of other people’s relationships to compare ours to. Instead of being limited to the people we see at school, work, church, or through mutual friends, we can scroll through seemingly endless alternatives on our phone.
All of this can make relationships feel disposable. If someone doesn’t match your vibe, you can just swipe until you find someone who does. And if a relationship becomes difficult, you can just slowly back away while looking for something easier. The modern term for that is “ghosting” someone.
Hookup culture has reinforced this mindset by separating intimacy from the commitment and responsibility that’s supposed to accompany a serious romantic relationship. Physical and emotional connection has become something many young adults pursue for what it gives them in the moment without asking what they owe the other person afterward.
People can and do use things like dating apps and social media to find meaningful, committed relationships (Emily and I met on a dating app and are approaching nine years of marriage). But they also present a trap that makes it easy and acceptable to compare your options, maximize your satisfaction, and move on when something no longer feels worth the investment.
This same mindset applies to how we approach friendships.
When it comes to platonic friendships, it’s a difference between “real friends” and “deal friends,” explains Adam Weber, founder and lead pastor of Embrace Church in Sioux Falls, South Dakota.
“When you find out that what you thought was a real friend is actually a deal friend, feeling used is probably the best description,” he says.
And no one wants to feel used.
“For me, what’s really fun is when a real friend also becomes a partner in the kingdom,” Weber says. “That’s when you have a real friendship, where I’m just with you because you’re my friend.”
The distinction extends beyond what someone can do for us materially. Sometimes we seek relationships because of what they say about us. We may gravitate toward people who are professionally successful because we think knowing them might help us become more successful, or at least be perceived as such. We might pursue friendships with people who have influence because we think their status will elevate our own. We can even begin to view people who seem to have little to offer us — professionally, financially, or socially — as unworthy of our limited time.
When we approach relationships like that, they just become another form of personal branding. We don’t just ask, “What can this person do for me?” We also ask, “What does being connected to this person do for me?”
And sometimes, we seek connection without actually having to connect. My friend E.J. LaRow explores this in his essay The Parasocial Generation, arguing that digitally based relationships can give young adults the feeling of intimacy without the risk, inconvenience, or obligation of real friendships. It’s a quick, low-effort method to satisfy the deep longing of connection.
In the world of college athletics, no one seems particularly eager to do anything to change the current situation because so many people benefit personally from the existing structure. Everyday life isn’t much different. We’re so caught up in our own work, life, goals, and responsibilities that it’s difficult to conceive of doing anything that doesn’t provide at least some tangible “reward,” be it personal, financial, or professional.
But this way of thinking and living is antithetical to our felt needs.
We Crave Deep Relationships But No Longer Prioritize Them
Humans are relational by nature because we were created by a relational God. Christians are commanded to model their lives after Jesus, who was as relational a human as there has ever been. Whether we realize it or not, we’re hardwired for connection with others.
Young adults long for deep relationships, yet many of us have relatively few close friends, data shows. The Pew Research Center found that 61% of Americans say having close friends is extremely or very important to living a fulfilling life, but among adults under 30, only 32% reported having five or more close friends.2
I have a theory on why this is the case. As children and adolescents, the social aspect of life was baked into everything we did. School encouraged us to socialize, to get involved in extracurriculars, and to make tons of friends. We understood that was part of the experience, and we prioritized it.
That didn’t change for those of us who went to college. For many of us, the social aspect was arguably half of the appeal. Whether we lived on campus or in apartments, we had groups of friends within close proximity that made it pretty easy to organize social gatherings. There was also no shortage of organizations or clubs that opened the door to quickly making a bunch of friends.
Once we hit adulthood, it’s like a flip immediately switched that told us we should no longer prioritize the social aspect of life because we now had to focus on making money, paying our bills, and advancing our career.
Unfortunately, there’s some legitimacy behind that thinking. More than 60% of Americans live paycheck to paycheck, and Millennials are the most likely generation to do so, according to a 2023 LendingClub report.3 Meanwhile, nearly half of Americans rely on a side hustle just to cover basic expenses. Millennials led the trend, with 66% reporting they have a side hustle and 41% saying their financial situation makes it hard to afford necessities, a 2023 Herbalife survey found.4
When time and money are hard to come by, we have to make difficult choices about where to spend both. As a result, many of us start viewing friendships as optional once we hit adulthood because paying bills isn’t.
“Part of it, I don’t even know if it’s by choice. It almost feels like necessity,” Weber says. “It’s like we need as many transactional relationships (as possible) and we don’t have time for our real friends.”
We’re also biologically wired to consider our own needs and what will help us stay safe, explains Nikki Klinglesmith, a Licensed Professional Counselor Associate in Texas. We think about things in terms of survival. What will help us pay the bills and put food on the table? What will help us get through the day?
“What is our actual capacity for friendship?” she asks. “I think there’s really high expectations, in a sense, because we’re such a digitally connected generation. But what can our bodies actually tolerate, and what’s actually good for us friendship wise?”
We also might carry an expectation to have more friendships than we can sustainably invest in, she adds.
“But at the same time, we get so overwhelmed to where we just shut down and we don’t invest in even a few friendships that may actually be healthy for us,” she says.
The Cost of Pursuing Deep Relationships
AARP’s 2026 Friendship Study, which was based on a nationally representative survey of nearly 1,500 U.S. adults, found that Americans report fewer close friends than five years ago and less frequent in-person interaction with friends.5 Along with work obligations, time constraints and a lack of social opportunities were among the most commonly cited barriers to making new friends.
That makes relationships more emotionally and mentally expensive, and these generations often don’t have the funds to afford them. They require time, inconvenience, patience, forgiveness, and sacrifice. They require continuing to show up when there’s no obvious benefit to doing so. They sometimes require putting someone else’s needs first when our innate desire is to think of ourselves.
“Most good things take sacrifice, showing up, making hard decisions and having hard conversations,” Weber says. “It takes discipline to have physical health. It takes discipline, in this day and age, to have strong mental health. And the same goes with friendship.”
The best friendships often have extremely poor short-term ROI, but that’s what makes them valuable.
“If you don’t invest in your friendships, they’re not going to be there,” Weber says. “At some point they’re going to stop calling and stop inviting you because you always flake out.”
While young adults long for deep relationships, many are prioritizing their free time toward activities that they feel help advance their career. Deloitte’s 2025 Gen Z and Millennial Survey of nearly 24,000 respondents across 44 countries found that 67% of Gen Z respondents spend their off hours developing work skills, which could include networking.6
Both generations said networking is the soft skill they consider most important for career advancement. On the surface, networking can feel like an attempt at forming relationships and scratching the itch we have toward connection. But these relationships usually come with potential tangible personal benefits on the other side. Rarely do we “network” for the sole purpose of making friends. There’s a clear benefit potential to both parties.
In a 2024 Empower Network Effect survey, 40% of Millennials said their personal connections helped them get their current job, compared with 31% of Americans overall. Forty percent of Millennials also said their network helped determine their salary, compared with 29% of respondents overall.7
Again, there’s nothing wrong with networking. Professional relationships matter, and genuine friendships can grow out of relationships that initially began for business purposes. But your intentions for pursuing the relationship matter.
If a person views time primarily as an investment in their future, relationships that don’t appear to contribute to that may become easier to neglect.
Consider a young writer at a literary conference. They could spend 30 minutes talking to another writer with interesting ideas but no obvious professional connections. Or they could spend that time chatting with an editor who might publish them, an established author who could connect them with an agent or other established writers who could help connect them with influential people. Many will choose the options that advance their career rather than spending that time developing what could become a meaningful friendship with the fellow writer, the data suggests.
Networking can open doors. But if every conversation is evaluated according to what it might eventually produce, we risk missing the relationships that have value precisely because they produce nothing for us other than a genuine connection.
“I think we’re hungry for real friends,” Weber says. “Yet most of us, or a lot of us, have deal friends. They’re like, ‘I’ve had some success in life and I’m no longer paycheck to paycheck, but I have nobody that I can call and say, hey, can you pray for me?’ ‘Hey, my marriage is kind of struggling.’ Hey, I’m kind of depressed, and I can’t tell my staff. I don’t really know who I can tell. I feel like I can’t tell anybody.’
“That’s the result of deal friends,” he says. “You might get where you want in life positionally, financially, whatever, but you won’t get to where you want in life relationally. And unfortunately, for us, we are relational creatures created by a relational God.”
A Different Kind of Return
Relationships that start off through networking can eventually have a direct effect on salary and career advancement. By extension, that can affect someone’s financial security and comfortability in life.
But when utility becomes the primary measure of a relationship’s value, we ignore the example from Jesus we’re supposed to be following.
The New Testament repeatedly describes love in terms of what someone is willing and able to give rather than what another person can provide. Jesus tells His followers to love their neighbors, show mercy, and make peace. He even tells them to love their enemies. In other words, draw close to people who offer no obvious benefit in return.
That’s part of the message behind Weber’s book, “Love Has a Name.” As Christians, we’re called to love those who are different from us or are just plain difficult to love.
“I always say ‘love people, use things,’ rather than ‘use people, love things,’” he says.
We can all probably point to an example or two where we’ve felt taken advantage of or taken for granted in a relationship. Sometimes we’re naive or too trustworthy of someone’s intentions. But sometimes our bodies can actually signal to use when something might be off relationally.
Within our nervous system are different stimuli that we experience — some that we’re conscious of and others that we aren’t, Klinglesmith says. She explains that when it comes to friendships, our body essentially has a protective mechanism that’s able to detect threats. Or alarm bells may start to go off if we feel like someone has ulterior motives for seeking a relationship.
This plays a role in the collective heightened anxiety among young adults and can hinder people from fully investing in relationships, she says.
“We go into a fight or flight or freeze state where we’re basically seeing relationships as a means to an end rather than people to connect with,” she says.
That mindset can make it harder to build the kind of relationships we say we want. But Jesus models the correct approach.
“There’s so many ‘one anothers’ throughout Scripture,” Weber says. “We have turned it into a very ‘me and Jesus’ type of thing, which is great, but where are all of those ‘one anothers’? That’s where we become more like Christ and where sanctification happens. That’s also the fruit of so much that we’re craving as human beings.”
Ultimately, don’t be so focused on selfish pursuits that you forget to build a life with people who can pray for you, celebrate with you, and pick you up when you’re down.
Most of life’s problems are only made worse in isolation.
“I don’t know how a person makes it through life without there being others to carry your mat, to keep arms raised when you can’t raise them yourself,” he says. “I also feel like your kingdom impact is so limited when you’re by yourself.
“Wherever two or more are gathered, God shows up in a way that we just can’t explain. I’ve seen that in my life. That’s when magic happens, and as a follower of Jesus, we need that. Every human needs it, but I think specifically as Christ followers we just need that.”
NCAA, “Student-Athlete Transfer Research,” accessed May 31, 2026, https://www.ncaa.org/what-we-do/research/student-athlete-transfer-research/.
Isabel Goddard, “What Does Friendship Look Like in America?,” Pew Research Center, October 12, 2023, https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/10/12/what-does-friendship-look-like-in-america/.
PYMNTS and LendingClub, New Reality Check: The Paycheck-to-Paycheck Report: The Generational Deep Dive Edition (April 2023), 8, PDF.
Herbalife, “Nearly Half of Americans Have Turned to Side Hustles and Other Forms of Supplemental Income in Today’s Challenging Economy, New Survey Finds,” April 11, 2023, https://www.herbalife.com/en-us/about-herbalife/press-room/press-releases/nearly-half-of-americans-have-turned-to-side-hustles-and-other-forms-of-supplemental-income-in-todays-challenging-economy-new-survey-finds.
AARP Research, “Friendship Study 2025,” AARP, 2025, https://www.aarp.org/pri/topics/social-leisure/relationships/friendship-study-2025/.
Elizabeth Faber, “Gen Zs and Millennials at Work: Pursuing a Balance of Money, Meaning, and Well-Being,” Deloitte Insights, June 2, 2025, https://www.deloitte.com/us/en/insights/topics/talent/2025-gen-z-millennial-survey.html.
The Currency Editors, “The Network Effect,” Empower, survey conducted August 5–7, 2024, accessed August 15, 2026, https://www.empower.com/the-currency/work/network-effect-research.




This is really good, Cole. I appreciate how you broke down the different types of relationships, as there is a place for career networking. The rise of transactional relationships I believe has something to do with the increasing me-focus in culture. What becomes most important is getting ahead and looking important, so real relationships get cut from the to-do list. I think if we can have even 1-2 real friends that is a blessing!
Great work on this, bro. I have felt transactional relationships can be so devastating in the ministry world specifically.